Thursday, September 4, 2014

ENGL 3225 Critique

Year: 2013-2014
Professor: David Luciano
Class: INGL 3225
College: University of Puerto Rico, Cayey Campus

Grace H. Rodríguez Cruz
ENGL3225- Introduction to Language
Prof. D.H. Luciano
March 10th, 2014
Humans have always wanted to find the answers of the mysteries of everyday life. Some may aim for space, and others may aim for closer grounds. Marc D. Hauser, Noam Chomsky and W. Tecumseh Fitch introduced the article: “ The Faculty of Language: What Is it Who has It and How Did It Evolve?” in which the main purpose of the writing is to explain the relation between the biology with and the linguistic outbreak the humans created to distinct themselves from other animals. “One aim of this essay is to promote a stronger connection between biology and linguistics by identifying points of contact and agreement between the fields.”
From the main topics, the authors mainly focus on proving how the faculty of language has a broad sense called the FLB and the narrow sense (FLN). The broad sense includes what provides the capacity to generate an infinite range of expressions from limited elements. These will include the  sensory-motor system, a conceptual-intentional system and the computational mechanisms of recursión. However, the FLN brings to the article the distinction of human exclusive components like using numbers, navigation systems and social relations.
The level of expertise of the authors is highly convincing due to the fact of all three of them domaining the topic of study. The authors convincingly talked with the Works and examples done by other fellow researchers such as Darwin, Boysen and Matsuzawa, Galileo, Descartes and so on to bring forth proof and to bring the thesis from their own works. The accuracy of the article was spot on in everything they explained, giving a table to proof the emphirical behaviors and pictures to make the visual learning easier. The article might be from the early 2000s, but it shows good domain and a still belieavable argument that dates today’s mystery with language.

In my opinion, the article is beautifuly written with logical proof and an enthusiasm for teaching others that I’ve rarely seen around a neuroscience article. I definitely agree with their aim and the relationship between the biological factor and the linguistic development because it has a good part of the “how” and the “why” language started.

No comments:

Post a Comment